Thursday, December 10, 2015

General Self-Assessment

Josue Cardoso
December 8, 2015
Prof. Stoll
Fiqws

When I initially came into college, I felt very secure about my writing skills. In high school, I took an advanced English class, which taught us the basic fundamentals of composing a well-developed, college level essay. Some of the fundamentals were citing sources that we took information from, composing several lengthy assignments, and properly using the MLA format. Walking into my Fiqws course with this knowledge, I assumed I was ahead of the game. Nevertheless, this course proved to sharpen my writing skills far more than I could’ve imagined.  

One of the very few first assignments that had been given was the reflective narrative assignment, which surrounded a passion of ours and its significance behind it. Like most of our assignments throughout the course, a first draft was first submitted, and then a revised version was finally given. However, in my previous writing courses, I had a tendency of submitting my first drafts as my final drafts; I thought that was good enough. Since I received fairly good grades by doing so in high school, I presumed it’d be the same thing. Yet, when I saw my grade which was equivalent to a B, I knew that the first drafts served a critical importance. In a sense, I felt as if this assignment was like a ‘wake-up call’, and ever since, I always read remarks made by other readers.

Another one of many assignments that had been given was a textual summary analysis; we were supposed to select an article that was somewhat relevant to our passion that we previously wrote about. After reading it, we were responsible for giving a summary of the article in our own words. I wound up writing about a biography of Arnold Schwarzenegger’s life and rise to fame through his body building dreams. After writing my first draft and receiving few remarks from peers, I was able to access a copy of my writing with helpful comments from my prof. Suggestions such as, making it completely clear that the topic of my essay was established within my thesis statement in the introduction. Also, making use of signal phrases which made reference to the source in which information was taken from. When I first heard about signal phrases, I wasn’t quite too sure of their purpose, but when they were properly inserted into my writing I was able to see their purpose. Not only did it switch up the vocabulary being used, but when reading the assignment over to myself, its flow sounded much smoother. I also really valued the feedback in areas where I may have been vague. I saw that as really helpful insight, because as the writer, we know the topic and any general knowledge pertaining to it, yet the reader might not. Pointing out areas, where more information is need helps the writer by letting them know their message isn’t being portrayed as they want it to be. Ultimately, with the aid of valuable feedback I was able to sharpen my writing piece and receive a far better grade than on my previous assignment.

One of my personal favorite assignments of the class was the argumentative written piece, which could’ve been in the basic essay format or in the form of the dialogue like many great philosophers wrote, such as Galileo and Gandhi. The task was to select a controversy, take a standpoint, and provide substantial evidence as to why we thought that was the correct approach. I chose to take the challenge of writing it in the form of a dialogue since I thought the use of characters to express an author’s personal beliefs was genius, as well as easier. However, I never wrote a dialogue before; although thanks to remarks that were made by a peer and professor, I was able to adjust things around. For instance, having each character take a stance in the controversy, in my situation the son and father were pro the teaching the of Darwin’s theory in schools, unlike the mom who was initially against it. My peer also mentioned to me that certain characters should elaborate more on statements that they made. He also reminded me to make several counter arguments that would pose a valuable opposition; which was what had given me the idea of making the mother the antagonist in the setting. Once again, because of peer reviews and assessments of first drafts, I was able to make a note of what I had a tendency to lack in throughout most of my assignments. Ultimately, I noticed that I get lazy in my writing towards the end sometimes, which is where I should be putting my best thoughts. The ending basically sums up everything that was touched upon, just not in great depth. 

Transitioning from high school to college, as previously stated, I thought I was ready for what was to be thrown at me in Fiqws. I could remember nagging to myself saying, ‘what’s the point of a first draft’. Well, with revisions and remarks made, and if they’re taken advantage of; the constructive criticism received from a first draft can be the difference of a B- to an A+ paper. Having others read your first draft gives you another perspective of what someone else may see that you don’t. The writer may think he fully addressed every topic in depth, but for some readers it may not be equally as evident. There’s also the possibility of them seeing a grammatical error that you didn’t pick up on. Needless to say, having others read your work won’t hurt. On the contrary, it’ll benefit the writer in the long run if they’re able to make enhancements as suggested.

Unfortunately, as the semester comes to a close, so do the courses; although I’ll never forget the valuable insight learned in developing my writing. Assuring myself that my introduction’s thesis summarizes the essay’s topic, the body paragraphs provide a sense of support, and the conclusion briefly wraps up topics that were mentioned. I felt that through these three main assignments, I was able to learn the most from and become a better writer. 


Monday, December 7, 2015

Final Draft: Textual Summary Analysis

Josue Cardoso
Essay #2: Textual Summary
September 27, 2015

   “There is more than meets the eye”; no other quote could be any more relevant to the life of former Californian governor, Arnold Schwarzenegger. In our modern day and age, most of us only know the Austrian Hollywood star as the man who played the role of the ‘Terminator’, or perhaps as the man who set the standards for bodybuilding. Little do most of us know it, but there’s a lot more common ground between the average American citizen, and the former Mr. Olympia.

   Born July 30, 1947 in Graz, Austria, Arnold Schwarzenegger was brought up by an alcoholic father who worked as a police chief, and apparently at one point was a member of the infamous Nazi party. Unfortunately for the future star, he was ridiculed by his father for his dream of one day hoping to become a body builder. This was due to the young Schwarzenegger’s small and scraggly body complexion in comparison to that of his brother’s. As if being mocked wasn’t enough, Arnold would endure beatings and acts of intimidation. The author didn’t fail to mention early on in the article about the countless times Arnold would be set up against his very own brother, by his father. In future interviews, Arnold would recall his childhood growing up as far from ideal; it was a very tense atmosphere within the Schwarzenegger household. It was because of the type of environment and abuse that he had undergone that lead to Arnold’s absence in both his father and brother’s funeral. Despite both mental and physical mistreatment as a child, Arnold wouldn’t let that stop him from pursuing his dreams. To serve as an outlet from the abuse at home, Arnold turned to films, particularly the American Reg Parker, who was a body builder playing the role of a B-grade Hercules. The author’s article reveals to us that through the influence of these films is what led to the development of Arnold’s desire to pursue a life in the land of the free known as America. Little did Arnold know that his impending fate would be made possible through the aid of Joe Weider, the man behind the Federation of Body Building. This federation was one of many which sponsored highly competitive body-building contests such as “Mr. Olympia” and “Mr. Universe”. When interviewed, Weider would share the insight he saw within Schwarzenegger, “bravado, sense of humor and potential”, undoubtedly he was right! Through sheer hard work and determination, Arnold Schwarzenegger would set the standard at an all-time high by winning the Mr. Olympia title six times, and the Mr. Universe crown five times!

   After winning an extraordinary amount of body building awards, Arnold’s life took a slight detour from body building to the acting industry. Sources would later reveal that ever since his childhood visits to the cinema back home in Austria, he had always had an aspiration of one day making it onto the big screen.  Of course at the time everyone knew of Arnold Schwarzenegger, not only through those who attended the competitions in which he competed in, but also after the release of the 1977 documentary Pumping Iron. The documentary surrounded Arnold as he defended his title for Mr. Olympia. Due to Schwarzenegger’s immense physique and incredible strength, he fit the perfect role for starring in action movies such as Conan The Barbarian, The Terminator series, The Expendables trilogy and Stay Hungry . It wasn’t too long afterwards that he would win a Golden Globe Award for best new coming actor for his role in Stay Hungry. To the general public, Arnold’s rise to fame seemed unbelievable; who would’ve thought that the young, scraggly, abused, and ridiculed Austrian boy would have ever made it this far in life? Although for those who actually knew Arnold Schwarzenegger personally, they saw nothing more than a bottomless pit of ambition within him. In shorter words, you could say that his hunger for success was never developed over time, because it had always been there and only grew hungrier. Being a crowned body builder and actor was not enough for the ambitious Austrian, as he would later run for the position of governor in the state of California and win! The author indicates that Schwarzenegger was stirred by former republican president, Ronald Reagan. As governor, Schwarzenegger would focus his attention on bettering the state’s financial adversities. Through acts of promoting new businesses and protecting the environment, he would later find himself being easily re-elected for a second term in the year of 2006. Unfortunately enough, Arnold’s second term didn’t run as smoothly and easy as his re-election. As some might refer to him as ‘The Governator’, he struggled to restore the state’s financial stability and ultimately wound up leaving his position in office by January of 2011. It’d be best to say that we’re all good at some things, but nobody is good at everything.

   There are several purposes as to why an author would compose a literary text; perhaps to persuade, or entertain its reader. Although in the previous article summarized, it’s obvious that the author’s main intention was to inform the reader about the life of Arnold Schwarzenegger. The author didn’t focus on any particular aspect of Schwarzenegger’s life, rather he compiled various critical moments throughout his life. From being abused as a child, to Arnold’s rise as a crowned body builder, later transitioning to his life as a popular Hollywood actor, and the role he played within California’s political system. It’s clear to say that the author intended for this article to be read and understood by a general audience instead of a specific group of people. If the author had been trying to grasp the attention of a specific group of people, he most likely would’ve focused on a particular point in Arnold Schwarzenegger’s life. For instance, if the author intended for the audience to be people who shared a similar passion of going to the gym, they would’ve fixated on Arnold’s life in the body building industry. It’s obvious to see that’s not the case based on the text. In addition, the author established an unbiased perspective on the life of Schwarzenegger from his mentioning of Arnold’s failure to better California’s financial situation and his love affairs within the shadows. The author didn’t fail to mention the subject’s triumphs, nor its blunders.

   The literary text served its purpose and was well accomplished by the author for various reasons. As previously mentioned he established an unbiased stance on the subject, and successfully touched upon various points throughout Arnold Schwarzenegger’s coming about. A general overview of the subject’s life was provided, while also being concise and informative. As one of many readers of this article, I could personally say that I was more than informed on the life and rise of Arnold Schwarzenegger.










Works Cited


1. "Arnold Schwarzenegger Biography." Bio.com. A&E Networks Television, n.d. Web. 29 Sept. 2015.

First Draft: Textual Summary Analyis

Josue Cardoso
Essay #2: Textual Summary
September 27, 2015

   “There is more than meets the eye”; no other quote could be any more relevant to the life of former Californian governor, Arnold Schwarzenegger. In our modern day and age, most of us only know the Austrian Hollywood star as the man who played the role of the ‘Terminator’, or perhaps as the man who set the standards for bodybuilding. Little do most of us know it, but there’s a lot more common ground between the average American citizen, and the former Mr. Olympia.

   Born July 30, 1947 in Graz, Austria, Arnold Schwarzenegger was brought up by an alcoholic father who worked as a police chief, and apparently at one point was a member of the infamous Nazi party. Unfortunately for the future star, he was ridiculed by his father for his dream of one day hoping to become a body builder. This was due to the young Schwarzenegger’s small and scraggly body complexion in comparison to that of his brother’s.  As if being mocked wasn’t enough, Arnold would endure beatings, acts of intimidation, and being set against his very own brother, by his father. In later interviews, Arnold would recall his childhood growing up as far from ideal; it was a very tense atmosphere within the Schwarzenegger household. It was because of the type of environment and abuse that he had undergone that lead to Arnold’s absence in both his father and brother’s funeral. Despite both mental and physical mistreatment as a child, Arnold wouldn’t let that stop him from pursuing his dreams. To serve as an outlet from the abuse at home, Arnold turned to films, particularly the American Reg Parker, who was a body builder playing the role of a B-grade Hercules. Through the influence of these films is what lead to the development of Arnold’s desire to pursue a life in the land of the free known as America. Little did Arnold know that his impending fate would be made possible through the aid of Joe Weider, the man behind the Federation of Body Building. This federation was one of many which sponsored highly competitive body-building contests such as “Mr. Olympia” and “Mr. Universe”. In later interviews, Weider would share that he saw “bravado, sense of humor and potential” in Schwarzenegger, undoubtedly he was right! Through sheer hard work and determination, Arnold Schwarzenegger would set the standard at an all-time high by winning the Mr. Olympia title six times, and the Mr. Universe crown five times!

   After winning an extraordinary amount of body building awards, Arnold’s life took a slight detour from body building to the acting industry. Sources would later reveal that ever since his childhood visits to the cinema back home in Austria, he had always had an aspiration of one day making it onto the big screen.  Of course at the time everyone knew of Arnold Schwarzenegger, not only through those who attended the competitions in which he competed in, but also after the release of the 1977 documentary Pumping Iron. The documentary surrounded Arnold as he defended his title for Mr. Olympia. Due to Schwarzenegger’s immense physique and incredible strength, he fit the perfect role for starring in action movies such as Conan The Barbarian, The Terminator series, The Expendables trilogy and Stay Hungry . It wasn’t too long afterwards that he would win a Golden Globe Award for best new coming actor for his role in Stay Hungry. To the general public, Arnold’s rise to fame seemed unbelievable; who would’ve thought that the young, scraggly, abused, and ridiculed Austrian boy would have ever made it this far in life? Although for those who actually knew Arnold Schwarzenegger personally, they saw nothing more than a bottomless pit of ambition within him. In shorter words, you could say that his hunger for success was never developed over time, because it had always been there and only grew hungrier. Being a crowned body builder and actor was not enough for the ambitious Austrian, as he would later run for the position of governor in the state of California and win! Being inspired by former president Ronald Reagan, governor Schwarzenegger would focus his attention on bettering the state’s financial adversities. Through acts of promoting new businesses and protecting the environment, he would later find himself being easily re-elected for a second term in the year of 2006. Unfortunately enough, Arnold’s second term didn’t run as smoothly and easy as his re-election. As some might refer to him as ‘The Governator’, he struggled to restore the state’s financial stability and ultimately wound up leaving his position in office by January of 2011. It’d be best to say that we’re all good at some things, but nobody is good at everything.

   There are several purposes as to why an author would compose a literary text; perhaps to persuade, or entertain its reader. Although in the previous article summarized, it’s obvious that the author’s main intention was to inform the reader about the life of Arnold Schwarzenegger. The author didn’t focus on any particular aspect of Schwarzenegger’s life, rather he compiled various critical moments throughout his life. From being abused as a child, to Arnold’s rise as a crowned body builder, later transitioning to his life as a popular Hollywood actor, and the role he played within California’s political system. It’s clear to say that the author intended for this article to be read and understood by a general audience instead of a specific group of people. If the author had been trying to grasp the attention of a specific group of people, he most likely would’ve focused on a particular point in Arnold Schwarzenegger’s life. For instance, if the author intended for the audience to be people who shared a similar passion of going to the gym, they would’ve fixated on Arnold’s life in the body building industry. It’s obvious to see that’s not the case based on the text. In addition, the author established an unbiased perspective on the life of Schwarzenegger from his mentioning of Arnold’s failure to better California’s financial situation and his love affairs within the shadows. The author didn’t fail to mention the subject’s triumphs, nor its blunders.

   The literary text served its purpose and was well accomplished by the author for various reasons. As previously mentioned he established an unbiased stance on the subject, and successfully touched upon various points throughout Arnold Schwarzenegger’s coming about. A general overview of the subject’s life was provided, while also being concise and informative. As one of many readers of this article, I could personally say that I was more than informed on the life and rise of Arnold Schwarzenegger.










Works Cited


Author: Biography.com
Title: Arnold Schwarzenegger
Publisher: A&E Television Networks
Media Type: Website
Website URL: 
http://www.biography.com/people/arnold-schwarzenegger-9476355#recent-publicity
Date Accessed: September 25, 2015

     

First & Final Draft: Reflective Narrative

Josue Cardoso
September 9, 2015
Fiqws

   In most of our lives we hold something in particular very close to us; something that nobody else can truly understand, but you. It’s something that plays a role in defining who you are. Others may feel this way towards playing an instrument, playing a sport, but I’d have to say I feel that way towards working out.

   Of course, I don’t believe I share a passion that most people would have. Working out wasn’t something that I loved to do right off the bat since I was a kid. It was more of a thing that I eventually picked up along my journeys of life. Since the day I was born, I was always more lenient towards the heavy side; being born nine pounds and twelve ounces. Growing up, we didn’t share most of the luxuries many might have had, but the last thing my siblings and I ever had to worry about was food. My mom always kept us well fed and clothed, and I guess along the way I was a bit too well fed. I remember at family reunions everyone would talk and catch up, and relatives would tell me that I was just going through a phase. Apparently, it was a phase that I’d eventually grow out of as I got older. Yet, when I hit the age of about thirteen or fourteen, I began to question whether what they said was true or not. Without a doubt I was called ‘fat’ or have had some jokes made in reference to my weight before, but beginning to hear it at home from siblings as well. Eventually it all began to take a toll, not only on my self-image, but as well as my self-esteem. When I’d go to school, I always preferred wearing a black shirt because it was one of my only shirts that sort of hid what they call ‘man boobs’; not forgetting to mention that black apparently made you look slimmer. Not a day went by that I didn’t check the mirror before I left the house to assure myself that they weren't noticeable, or at least not as noticeable.  I guess it was that point in my life, where we all go through an awkward phase, and after hearing comments being made more frequently, I knew I wanted to do something about it. It's not like I was never active as a kid, because I was always running around in the backyard, running errands on my bike, or partaking in some exercise. Although, I didn't always make the best decisions when it came to what I ate,and how much of it I ate. All in all, it's something that I ultimately feel that I did to myself; and as my mom always said "You got yourself in, now get yourself out". That was exactly what I intended on doing.

   Transitioning from middle school to high school may have been the turning point. Entering my freshman year, I weighed roughly about 180 pounds and was always encouraged to play football due to my broad built. I always said I'd think about but never ever really took the time to do so. That was until October of 2011, when offseason practices began. There the football team weight lifted or conducted pliometric exercises that would aid in bettering a player's overall athletic performance. I remember my first day in there picking up weights heavier than others, it was a proud feeling to have. Adjusting myself just right on the bench to assure I'd be comfortable while lifting, looking up at the 2' x 3' tiles in the ceiling, and pressing my hands against the rusty iron grip of the bar. Inhaling and exhaling, repetitively three times, and once I was ready I gripped the bar and did my first six reps of 135 lbs. From that day forward, weight lifting was something I would always love to do, despite the next day's insane body soreness. It's like how they say, 'The soreness from a previous day's workout is the best worst feeling; meaning it's the best pain to have. Being a football player and all, I had the guidance of a coach who told us what foods to stay away from, and what to load up on. If there were days we didn't have practice over an extended period of time, he'd tell us to make sure we worked out on our own time. Following the advice of my coach, I hit a local YMCA's weight room, and steered clear of foods I was warned about. Within time, I myself didn't notice it much, but the weight began to shed off and was replaced by muscle. Little did I know that the following football season would be one Saunders Trades & Technical High School's best football records to be set, a winning season record of 6-1. I continued to play football, but after I turned sixteen and began to work, I worked out on my own a lot more since my work schedule didn’t coincide with the offseason program, which wasn’t mandatory. Within that time span up until my senior year, I experimented with several ways of working out, such as power lifting, which pertained to lifting more weight and doing a lesser number of reps. On other days I would switch it up and get a comfortable weight that I could do a good number of reps with. In preparation for my senior year of football, I dedicated my entire free time to becoming a valuable asset for my team by following my own strict weight lifting methods. I weighed approximately 190 lbs. in December 2013, and by June I weighed 230 lbs. It was a 230 lbs of muscle; a weight that I worked hard to attain. I could feel the difference. I continuously aimed to break personal records; the 225 lbs. that I struggled to bench three times my sophomore year, I was now using it as the weight that I’d warm up with before beginning my actual workout. I could honestly say I was at a peak, benching 315 lbs., squatting 435 lbs., and being able to power clean 200 lbs. It wasn’t weight that just any average seventeen year old adolescent could be throwing up. Unfortunately, my preparations went to a waste due to an altercation with the new head coach, which lead to me being removed from the team. It was a sad way to see my last year of football being taken away from me, and to this very day I still wish I could throw on those shoulder pads again. One thing for sure is that I’ll forever be grateful to the sport of football, because otherwise I would’ve never been introduced to weightlifting.

   Everyone has some form of passion, which may have been developed since early childhood or perhaps along the ups and downs of life. Whatever that may be, it’s something that only that one person can ever really see the full significance of. In my circumstance, working out for me was an outlet. Whenever I would weight lift, I remembered all the things that were said to me, and used it as something to push off of. Typically, when you hear stories of people who struggle with their weight, they tend to eat away their feelings or resort to something else, but I wasn’t having it. Once I began seeing results and a difference in myself, I realized that I never wanted to revert to being the little fat kid I once was.   



Final Draft: Argumentative Essay

Josue Cardoso
November 15, 2015
Prof. Stoll
Argumentative Essay

            On a breezy Thursday afternoon, fourteen year old Dylan Bryan makes his way home uneasy to share with the rest of his family what he had learned that day in his 9th grade biology class; the theory of evolution. He just knew his mom was going to have a mouthful when he mentioned it; he wished they would never ask how his school day went. Nevertheless, the idea of Darwin’s theory had always sparked a keen interest in the young adolescent. To Dylan it was as if it were a starting point for mankind.  Dreading the moment his mother yelled for him to set up the dinner table, unaware of his surroundings, Dylan nearly bumped into his mother’s beloved portrait of ‘The Last Supper’. Yet, he didn’t see the big deal considering the fact that his six foot tall dad broke the same portrait numerous times and simply replaced it with a new one immediately before his mom could notice. Slowly and uneasily, Dylan finally sets the table, ‘fork, fork, plate, knife with the blade facing inward, and spoon’; just as mother had shown him. Nervously, Dylan watches his father take his seat at the head of the table, and his mother sits across from Dylan, in front of the crucifix that they’ve had since he could remember.
Dylan: Everything smells great mom, I don’t know where to begin.
Mother: I know! How about you start off by telling me about your school day?
Dylan: Geez mom, what about dad’s day?
Mom: Well, he’s not the one in his freshman year of high school?
Dylan: Alright well, in biology today Mr. Dorkins taught us Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution; you know, the whole concept of all living things deriving from a common ancestor.
Father: Is that right? How about you explain into further detail what it is that you were exactly taught?
Dylan: Sure pops, so basically a few hundred years ago this guy named Charles Darwin was conducting boat loads of research, and he stumbled across something pretty neat in his findings. He noticed that two birds that had looked nearly identical were in fact two different species, even though both of the birds inhabited climates that were relatively the same. So he basically came to the conclusion that both of these birds must have come from a common ancestor due to the large number of similarities that they both shared (Darwin’s Dangerous Idea).
Father: And do you know what determines those selected similarities?
Dylan: Oh yeah! So those common features shared amongst the species were determined based on the environment that they lived in. The species that would develop traits that helped in its adaptation to its environment would reproduce, although other species who were unable to adapt to their environments would eventually go extinct (Darwin’s Dangerous Idea).
Father: Henceforth, the saying ‘Survival of the Fittest’ (Charles Darwin).
Dylan: Yeah that’s right! Mr. Dorkins also mentioned that man could have common ancestral roots similar to those of chimps.
Mother: Oh for the love of..
Father: I remember when I was a boy, we weren’t allowed to be exposed to such new theories; it was always ‘Jesus this’ and ‘The bible says that’. I think it’s great that your teacher is teaching you something that my generation was never taught.
Mother: I’LL HAVE YOU KNOW THAT I’M NOT RELATED TO ANY MONKEY!
Dylan: Woah woah, mom, take it easy; nobody ever said you were. It was just a concept that derived from Darwin’s theory.
Mother: I raised you better than that young man; we are a Christian household that worships the lord, believes in the origins of the Bible, and attends mass regularly. I will not have any child of mine going against our household morals! I know you’ve read the Book of Genesis in your Sunday school classes. In case you haven’t though, it states that God created man, and this planet that we all inhabit. (Book of Genesis 2.1-2.2). Receiving an education is one thing, but affecting the beliefs of my son is another; I will simply not have it! 
Dylan: Mom, relax. Mr. Dorkins said you might react that way if we did mention this topic at our dinner tables. He isn’t affecting my moral beliefs whatsoever, in fact he’s just made me think of how far the human race has come. He told us as a ninth grade biology teacher, that evolution was the renowned theory that underlies all living sciences; we’ve come so far because of it! Just look around you!
Mother: Dylan, I would like you to listen to me very clearly in what I am about to tell you.
Dylan: But mom if you would just..
Mom: Generations ago, people would escape their horrid homelands in pursuit of a better life here in America; that I'm sure you are aware of. A better life where they can make their dreams a reality, a place for a new start, but most importantly a place to practice any religion free of persecution. Now the school system wants to teach my precious baby boy that what I’m teaching him is wrong?!
Dylan: But mom nobody ever said it was, after all everyone here in this beautiful country of ours is free to practice any religion that their heart desires. America doesn’t have one national religion, and neither does the school system.
Mother: I am going to march down there first thing tomorrow morning and give not only that teacher a piece of my mind, but as well as the principal and superintendent. When did it ever become alright for the principles that I teach my son to be contradicted?
Father: Well I don’t see the big deal. The boy’s being educated on topics that were never addressed to us. This is vital information that needs to be passed onto future generations! Without scientific theories like this being passed on, our kids are going to be lagging behind others who were taught it.
Mother: I can understand what you are saying, but these teachings are ultimately going to shift what Dylan believes in.
Dylan: But it won’t mom! Before you cut me off, I was going to tell you how the concepts of Darwin’s theory are used in advancements in medicine today.
Mother: How so?
Dylan: Well, after class I looked into how relevant Darwin’s theory is in today’s world.
Mother: And?
Dylan: Turns out that in the treatment of HIV and AIDS, the virus is constantly evolving and developing an immunity to the medications that the patient is exposed to. Although with this intel, doctors have developed strategies where they’ll expose the patient to treatments, then suddenly cut them off in belief that the virus would revert to its old self, and once again be susceptible to the medications (Darwin’s Dangerous Idea).
Father: That’s the first time I see you take such strong interest in a school related topic son.
Dylan: I mean I just see it as a necessary building block to truly understanding one day where we all came from.
Mother: Well, let’s say I’m not necessarily referring to you, but what about the other kids? What if their opinions are changed because of Darwin’s Theory? I’m almost certain no parent is gonna be glad to have their child come home and tell them that what they were taught prior to that day is false. One day they’re told that they were made in God’s image, then the next they are taught that they come from a common ancestor as an ape.
Father: Oh geez, next thing you know your mother’s going to be like those folks in Kansas who tried changing the standard definition of science.
Mother: Are you mocking me?!
Father: No my love, of course not. I’m just saying you’re going to take action and wind up wrong. For instance, in Kansas these folks felt that the definition of science needed to be changed, however many strongly argued that the definition left room for the possibility of a supernatural explanation. On top of that, the redefined definition was being established by a board who weren’t even educators. They don’t know what they’re talking about! How can they possibly try to redefine a word that they don’t know the meaning of? It’s like having a mechanic fix your sink, and a plumber setting up your cable. Anyways, at the end of it all the National Academy of Science refused to allow the use of its copyrighted National Science Education standards. Also, the American Association for the Advancement of Science and the National Science Teachers Association refused to allow Kansas to use their material within writing the new standards (Jim Dawson). Guess they didn’t agree much with what Kansas had to think. 

Dylan: Actually mom, if you were unaware; there are actually some states where the teaching of evolution in the classrooms is fought for.
Mother: Name one.
Dylan: Gladly. So in Pennsylvania a local registered nurse and physics teacher chose to run for positions in the school board after coming to the realization that opinions weren’t very welcomed. The physics teacher claimed to have witnessed bible scriptures being yelled and taunting at those who disagreed. It later turned out that the school was feeding the kids information about intellectual design which some saw as unconstitutional since it was also considered religious creationism (Jim Dawson).
Mother: So what are you getting at?
Dylan: Well, basically the parents felt it was unjust for the kids to be exposed to simply intellectual design; they wanted them to be exposed to Darwin’s theory and such. Did you know that in this trial, some biology teachers claimed that evolution wasn’t a fact (Jim Dawson)?
Father: That’s odd; you’d think the biology teachers would be the ones having the bible scriptures being yelled at them.
Mother: Coincidentally, Martha, the next door neighbor’s daughter who came back home from college was telling me about a trial she just finished analyzing for her law class.
Dylan: How’s that relate to the topic mom?
Mother: Well, Martha told me it was this big trial back in the mid 1920’s in Dayton.
Father: That’s in Tennessee.
Mother: Yeah, so apparently this guy by the name of John Scopes was arrested for the teaching of evolution.
Dylan: Yeah, but here on my phone says that he was only arrested because of the governor’s carelessness in enacting a bill which made it illegal to teach evolution in the school systems. The things the guy would do for the rural population’s vote. See mom; that just goes to show you that our own elected official don’t even feel that strongly towards the matter as you do. As a matter of fact they probably share the same standpoint as dad and I.
Mother: Hmm, Martha mentioned something along those lines; it was so long ago that it’s coming back in bits and pieces.
Dylan: Did you also know that the defendant won his case due to the opposition’s lack in knowledge? Yep, turned out that William Jennings Bryan wasn’t the full blown fundamentalist that everyone thought he was (Roger Hudson).
Mother: Well, that she did fail to mention..
Father: Honey, I get the perspective that you’re looking from.
Mother: No, I don’t think you do! What gives them the right to go around teaching theories that contradict our beliefs? It’s a slap in face! A way of them saying, ‘we’re right and you’re wrong’. So much for freedom of religion.
Dylan: But mom, nobody’s forcibly imposing these ideas on me. Regardless, as I grow up I’m going to believe in what I want to anyways, right?
Mother: Well, you bring up a good point there, but you’re still my baby boy.
Father: Honey, there’s more good that can be foreseen with the teaching of Darwin’s theory than bad. In fact, I’m more than certain if we never accepted Darwin’s theory as a nation, we’d probably be back tracked scientifically.
Mother: I suppose you two are right, there’s no need for me to get so fired up. After all, both of you did provide reasons as to why it should be encouraged in schools.
Father: Great, now that our riveting debate has come to a close; since Dylan was so anxious to get dinner started, he can be anxious to clean up the table.
Dylan: That reminds me, I have homework and two tests tomorrow.
Mother: Better get started then!




Works Cited
1. “BibleGateway." Genesis 2 NASB. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2015
2. "Darwin's Dangerous Idea." YouTube. YouTube, 27 July 2012. Web. 12 Oct. 2015.
3. Darwin, Charles. Origin of Species. London: Charles Darwin, 1859. Gutenburg.org. Sue Asscher and David Widger, 23 Nov. 2009. Web. 18 Oct. 2015.
4. Hudson, Roger. "The Monkey Trial." History Today 65.7 (2015): 26-27. Academic Search Complete. Web. 10 Nov. 2015.

5. Dawson, Jim. "Evolution Wins In Pennsylvania, Loses In Kansas." Physics Today 59.1 (2006): 32-33. Academic Search Complete. Web. 10 Nov. 2015.

First Draft: Argumentative Essay

Josue Cardoso
November 15, 2015
Prof. Stoll
Argumentative Essay

     On a breezy Thursday afternoon, fourteen year old Dylan Bryan makes his way home eager to share with the rest of his family what he had learned that day in his 9th grade biology class. He knew that the perfect time to share his freshly gained knowledge would be when he takes his seat at the family dinner table. Ambitious, Dylan claims he’s starving in order to get an early start on dinner preparations, but as he’s rushing nearly bumps into his mother’s beloved portrait of ‘The Last Supper’. Yet, he didn’t see the big deal considering the fact that his six foot tall dad broke the same portrait numerous times and simply replaced it with a new one immediately before his mom could notice. Scurrying along, Dylan finally sets the table, ‘fork, fork, plate, knife with the blade facing inward, and spoon’; just as mother had shown him. Forcing away his smile, Dylan watches his father take his seat at the head of the table, and his mother sits across from Dylan, in front of the crucifix that they’ve had since he could remember.

Dylan: Everything smells great mom, I don’t know where to begin.
Mother: I know! How about you start off by telling me about your school day?
Dylan: Well, in biology today Mr. Dorkins taught us Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution; you know, the whole concept of all living things deriving from a common ancestor.
Father: Is that right? How about you explain into further detail what it is that you were exactly taught?
Dylan: Sure pops, so basically a few hundred years ago this guy named Charles Darwin was conducting boat loads of research, and he stumbled across something pretty neat in his findings. He noticed that two birds that had looked nearly identical were in fact two different species, even though both of the birds inhabited climates that were relatively the same. So he basically came to the conclusion that both of these birds must have come from a common ancestor due to the large number of similarities that they both shared.
Father: And do you know what determines those selected similarities?
Dylan: Oh yeah! So those common features shared amongst the species were determined based on the environment that they lived in. The species that would develop traits that helped in its adaptation to its environment would reproduce, although other species who were unable to adapt to their environments would eventually go extinct.
Father: Henceforth, the saying ‘Survival of the Fittest’
Dylan: Yeah that’s right! Mr. Dorkins also mentioned that man could have common ancestral roots similar to those of chimps.
Mother: Oh for the love of..
Father: I remember when i was a boy, we weren’t allowed to be exposed to such new theories; it was always ‘Jesus this’ and ‘The bible says that’. I think it’s great that your teacher is teaching you something that my generation was never taught.
Mother: I’LL HAVE YOU KNOW THAT I’M NOT RELATED TO ANY MONKEY!
Dylan: Woah woah, mom, take it easy; nobody ever said you were. It was just a concept that derived from Darwin’s theory.
Mother: I raised you better than that young man; we are a Christian household that worships the lord, believes in the origins of the Bible, and attends mass regularly. I will not have any child of mine going against our household morals!
Dylan: Mom, relax. Mr. Dorkins said you might react that way if we did mention this topic at our dinner tables. He isn’t affecting my moral beliefs whatsoever, in fact he’s just made me think of how far the human race has come.
Mother: Dylan, I would like you to listen to me very clearly in what I am about to tell you.
Dylan: But mom if you would just..
Mom: Generations ago, people would escape their horrid homelands in pursuit of a better life here in America; that I'm sure you are aware of. A better life where they can make their dreams a reality, a place for a new start, but most importantly a place to practice any religion free of persecution. Now the school system wants to teach my precious baby boy that what I’m teaching him is wrong?!
Dylan: But mom nobody ever said it was..
Mother: I am going to march down there first thing tomorrow morning and give not only that teacher a piece of my mind, but as well as the principal and superintendent. When did it ever become alright for the principles that I teach my son to be contradicted?
Father: Well I don’t see the big deal. The boy’s being educated on topics that were never addressed to us. This is vital information that needs to be passed onto future generations! Without scientific theories like this being passed on, our kids are going to be lagging behind others who were taught it.
Mother: I can understand what you are saying, but these teachings are ultimately going to shift what Dylan believes in.
Dylan: But it won’t mom! Before you cut me off, I was going to tell you how the concepts of Darwin’s theory are used in advancements in medicine today.
Mother: How so?
Dylan: Well, after class I looked into how relevant Darwin’s theory is in today’s world.
Mother: And?
Dylan: Turns out that in the treatment of HIV and AIDS, the virus is constantly evolving and developing an immunity to the medications that the patient is exposed to. Although with this intel, doctors have developed strategies where they’ll expose the patient to treatments, then suddenly cut them off in belief that the virus would revert to its old self, and once again be susceptible to the medications.
Father: That’s the first time I see you take such strong interest in a school related topic son.
Mother: Well, let’s say I’m not necessarily referring to you, but what about the other kids? What if their opinions are changed because of Darwin’s Theory? I’m almost certain no parent is gonna be glad to have their child come home and tell them that what they were taught prior to that day is false. One day they’re told that they were made in God’s image, then the next they are taught that they come from a common ancestor as an ape.
Father: Oh geez, next thing you know your mother’s going to be like those folks in Kansas who tried changing the standard definition of science.
Mother: Are you mocking me?!
Father: No my love, of course not. I’m just saying you’re going to take action and wind up wrong. For instance, in Kansas these folks felt that the definition of science needed to be changed, and the definition that it had been changed to left room for the possibility of a supernatural explanation. What made it worse was that the redefined definition wasn’t trying to be established by a board that weren’t all educators. They don’t know what they’re talking about! How can they possibly try to redefine a word that they don’t know the meaning of? It’s like having a mechanic fix your sink, and a plumber setting up your cable.
Dylan: Actually mom, if you were unaware; there are actually some states where the teaching of evolution in the classrooms is fought for.
Mother: Name one.
Dylan: Gladly. So in Pennsylvania a local registered nurse and physics teacher chose to run for positions in the school board after coming to the realization that opinions weren’t very welcomed. The physics teacher claimed to have witnessed bible scriptures being yelled and taunting at those who disagreed. It later turned out that the school was feeding the kids information about intellectual design which some saw as unconstitutional since it was also considered religious creationism.
Mother: So what are you getting at?
Dylan: Well, basically the parents felt it was unjust for the kids to be exposed to simply intellectual design; they wanted them to be exposed to Darwin’s theory and such. Did you know that in this trial, some biology teachers claimed that evolution wasn’t a fact?
Father: That’s odd; you’d think the biology teachers would be the ones having the bible scriptures being yelled at them.
Mother: Coincidentally, Martha, the next door neighbor’s daughter who came back home from college was telling me about a trial she just finished analyzing for her law class.
Dylan: How’s that relate to the topic mom?
Mother: Well, Martha told me it was this big trial back in the mid 1920’s in Dayton.
Father: That’s in Tennessee.
Mother: Yeah, so apparently this guy by the name of John Scopes was arrested for the teaching of evolution.
Dylan: Yeah, but here on my phone says that he was only arrested because of the governor’s carelessness in enacting a bill which made it illegal to teach evolution in the school systems. The things the guy would do for the rural population’s vote.
Mother: Martha mentioned something along those lines as well.
Dylan: Did you also know that the defendant won his case due to the opposition’s lack in knowledge? Yep, turned out that William Jennings Bryan wasn’t the full blown fundamentalist that everyone thought he was.
Mother: Well, that she did fail to mention..
Father: Honey, I get the perspective that you’re looking from.
Mother: No, I don’t think you do! What gives them the right to go around teaching theories that contradict our beliefs? It’s a slap in face! A way of them saying, ‘we’re right and you’re wrong’. So much for freedom of religion.
Dylan: But mom, nobody’s forcibly imposing these ideas on me. Regardless, as I grow up I’m going to believe in what I want to anyways right?
Mother: Well, you bring up a good point there, but you’re still my baby boy.
Father: Honey, there’s more good that can be foreseen with the teaching of Darwin’s theory than bad. In fact, I’m more than certain if we never accepted Darwin’s theory as a nation, we’d probably be back tracked scientifically.
Mother: I suppose you two are right, there’s no need for me to get so fired up. Afterall, both of you did provide reasons as to why it should be encouraged in schools.
Father: Great, now that our riveting debate has come to a close; since Dylan was so anxious to get dinner started, he can be anxious to clean up the table.
Dylan: That reminds me, I have homework and two tests tomorrow.

Mother: Better get started then!