Josue Cardoso
November 15, 2015
Prof. Stoll
Argumentative Essay
On
a breezy Thursday afternoon, fourteen year old Dylan Bryan makes his way home
uneasy to share with the rest of his family what he had learned that day in his
9th grade biology class; the theory of evolution. He just knew his mom was
going to have a mouthful when he mentioned it; he wished they would never ask
how his school day went. Nevertheless, the idea of Darwin’s theory had always
sparked a keen interest in the young adolescent. To Dylan it was as if it were
a starting point for mankind. Dreading the
moment his mother yelled for him to set up the dinner table, unaware of his
surroundings, Dylan nearly bumped into his mother’s beloved portrait of ‘The
Last Supper’. Yet, he didn’t see the big deal considering the fact that his six
foot tall dad broke the same portrait numerous times and simply replaced it
with a new one immediately before his mom could notice. Slowly and uneasily,
Dylan finally sets the table, ‘fork, fork, plate, knife with the blade facing
inward, and spoon’; just as mother had shown him. Nervously, Dylan watches his
father take his seat at the head of the table, and his mother sits across from
Dylan, in front of the crucifix that they’ve had since he could remember.
Dylan: Everything
smells great mom, I don’t know where to begin.
Mother: I know! How
about you start off by telling me about your school day?
Dylan: Geez mom, what
about dad’s day?
Mom: Well, he’s not the
one in his freshman year of high school?
Dylan: Alright well, in
biology today Mr. Dorkins taught us Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution; you
know, the whole concept of all living things deriving from a common ancestor.
Father: Is that right?
How about you explain into further detail what it is that you were exactly
taught?
Dylan: Sure pops, so
basically a few hundred years ago this guy named Charles Darwin was conducting
boat loads of research, and he stumbled across something pretty neat in his
findings. He noticed that two birds that had looked nearly identical were in
fact two different species, even though both of the birds inhabited climates
that were relatively the same. So he basically came to the conclusion that both
of these birds must have come from a common ancestor due to the large number of
similarities that they both shared (Darwin’s Dangerous Idea).
Father: And do you know
what determines those selected similarities?
Dylan: Oh yeah! So
those common features shared amongst the species were determined based on the
environment that they lived in. The species that would develop traits that
helped in its adaptation to its environment would reproduce, although other
species who were unable to adapt to their environments would eventually go
extinct (Darwin’s Dangerous Idea).
Father: Henceforth, the
saying ‘Survival of the Fittest’ (Charles Darwin).
Dylan: Yeah that’s
right! Mr. Dorkins also mentioned that man could have common ancestral roots
similar to those of chimps.
Mother: Oh for the love
of..
Father: I remember when
I was a boy, we weren’t allowed to be exposed to such new theories; it was
always ‘Jesus this’ and ‘The bible says that’. I think it’s great that your
teacher is teaching you something that my generation was never taught.
Mother: I’LL HAVE YOU
KNOW THAT I’M NOT RELATED TO ANY MONKEY!
Dylan: Woah woah, mom,
take it easy; nobody ever said you were. It was just a concept that derived
from Darwin’s theory.
Mother: I raised you
better than that young man; we are a Christian household that worships the
lord, believes in the origins of the Bible, and attends mass regularly. I will
not have any child of mine going against our household morals! I know you’ve
read the Book of Genesis in your Sunday school classes. In case you haven’t
though, it states that God created man, and this planet that we all inhabit.
(Book of Genesis 2.1-2.2). Receiving an education is one thing, but affecting
the beliefs of my son is another; I will simply not have it!
Dylan: Mom, relax. Mr.
Dorkins said you might react that way if we did mention this topic at our
dinner tables. He isn’t affecting my moral beliefs whatsoever, in fact he’s
just made me think of how far the human race has come. He told us as a ninth
grade biology teacher, that evolution was the renowned theory that underlies
all living sciences; we’ve come so far because of it! Just look around you!
Mother: Dylan, I would
like you to listen to me very clearly in what I am about to tell you.
Dylan: But mom if you
would just..
Mom: Generations ago,
people would escape their horrid homelands in pursuit of a better life here in
America; that I'm sure you are aware of. A better life where they can make
their dreams a reality, a place for a new start, but most importantly a place
to practice any religion free of persecution. Now the school system wants to
teach my precious baby boy that what I’m teaching him is wrong?!
Dylan: But mom nobody
ever said it was, after all everyone here in this beautiful country of ours is
free to practice any religion that their heart desires. America doesn’t have
one national religion, and neither does the school system.
Mother: I am going to
march down there first thing tomorrow morning and give not only that teacher a
piece of my mind, but as well as the principal and superintendent. When did it
ever become alright for the principles that I teach my son to be contradicted?
Father: Well I don’t
see the big deal. The boy’s being educated on topics that were never addressed
to us. This is vital information that needs to be passed onto future
generations! Without scientific theories like this being passed on, our kids
are going to be lagging behind others who were taught it.
Mother: I can
understand what you are saying, but these teachings are ultimately going to
shift what Dylan believes in.
Dylan: But it won’t
mom! Before you cut me off, I was going to tell you how the concepts of
Darwin’s theory are used in advancements in medicine today.
Mother: How so?
Dylan: Well, after
class I looked into how relevant Darwin’s theory is in today’s world.
Mother: And?
Dylan: Turns out that
in the treatment of HIV and AIDS, the virus is constantly evolving and
developing an immunity to the medications that the patient is exposed to.
Although with this intel, doctors have developed strategies where they’ll
expose the patient to treatments, then suddenly cut them off in belief that the
virus would revert to its old self, and once again be susceptible to the
medications (Darwin’s Dangerous Idea).
Father: That’s the
first time I see you take such strong interest in a school related topic son.
Dylan: I mean I just
see it as a necessary building block to truly understanding one day where we
all came from.
Mother: Well, let’s say
I’m not necessarily referring to you, but what about the other kids? What if
their opinions are changed because of Darwin’s Theory? I’m almost certain no
parent is gonna be glad to have their child come home and tell them that what
they were taught prior to that day is false. One day they’re told that they
were made in God’s image, then the next they are taught that they come from a
common ancestor as an ape.
Father: Oh geez, next
thing you know your mother’s going to be like those folks in Kansas who tried
changing the standard definition of science.
Mother: Are you mocking
me?!
Father: No my love, of
course not. I’m just saying you’re going to take action and wind up wrong. For
instance, in Kansas these folks felt that the definition of science needed to
be changed, however many strongly argued that the definition left room for the
possibility of a supernatural explanation. On top of that, the redefined
definition was being established by a board who weren’t even educators. They
don’t know what they’re talking about! How can they possibly try to redefine a
word that they don’t know the meaning of? It’s like having a mechanic fix your
sink, and a plumber setting up your cable. Anyways, at the end of it all the
National Academy of Science refused to allow the use of its copyrighted
National Science Education standards. Also, the American Association for the
Advancement of Science and the National Science Teachers Association refused to
allow Kansas to use their material within writing the new standards (Jim
Dawson). Guess they didn’t agree much with what Kansas had to think.
Dylan: Actually mom, if
you were unaware; there are actually some states where the teaching of evolution
in the classrooms is fought for.
Mother: Name one.
Dylan: Gladly. So in
Pennsylvania a local registered nurse and physics teacher chose to run for
positions in the school board after coming to the realization that opinions
weren’t very welcomed. The physics teacher claimed to have witnessed bible
scriptures being yelled and taunting at those who disagreed. It later turned
out that the school was feeding the kids information about intellectual design
which some saw as unconstitutional since it was also considered religious
creationism (Jim Dawson).
Mother: So what are you
getting at?
Dylan: Well, basically
the parents felt it was unjust for the kids to be exposed to simply
intellectual design; they wanted them to be exposed to Darwin’s theory and
such. Did you know that in this trial, some biology teachers claimed that
evolution wasn’t a fact (Jim Dawson)?
Father: That’s odd;
you’d think the biology teachers would be the ones having the bible scriptures
being yelled at them.
Mother: Coincidentally,
Martha, the next door neighbor’s daughter who came back home from college was
telling me about a trial she just finished analyzing for her law class.
Dylan: How’s that
relate to the topic mom?
Mother: Well, Martha
told me it was this big trial back in the mid 1920’s in Dayton.
Father: That’s in
Tennessee.
Mother: Yeah, so
apparently this guy by the name of John Scopes was arrested for the teaching of
evolution.
Dylan: Yeah, but here
on my phone says that he was only arrested because of the governor’s carelessness
in enacting a bill which made it illegal to teach evolution in the school
systems. The things the guy would do for the rural population’s vote. See mom;
that just goes to show you that our own elected official don’t even feel that
strongly towards the matter as you do. As a matter of fact they probably share
the same standpoint as dad and I.
Mother: Hmm, Martha
mentioned something along those lines; it was so long ago that it’s coming back
in bits and pieces.
Dylan: Did you also
know that the defendant won his case due to the opposition’s lack in knowledge?
Yep, turned out that William Jennings Bryan wasn’t the full blown
fundamentalist that everyone thought he was (Roger Hudson).
Mother: Well, that she
did fail to mention..
Father: Honey, I get
the perspective that you’re looking from.
Mother: No, I don’t
think you do! What gives them the right to go around teaching theories that
contradict our beliefs? It’s a slap in face! A way of them saying, ‘we’re right
and you’re wrong’. So much for freedom of religion.
Dylan: But mom,
nobody’s forcibly imposing these ideas on me. Regardless, as I grow up I’m
going to believe in what I want to anyways, right?
Mother: Well, you bring
up a good point there, but you’re still my baby boy.
Father: Honey, there’s
more good that can be foreseen with the teaching of Darwin’s theory than bad.
In fact, I’m more than certain if we never accepted Darwin’s theory as a
nation, we’d probably be back tracked scientifically.
Mother: I suppose you
two are right, there’s no need for me to get so fired up. After all, both of
you did provide reasons as to why it should be encouraged in schools.
Father: Great, now that
our riveting debate has come to a close; since Dylan was so anxious to get
dinner started, he can be anxious to clean up the table.
Dylan: That reminds me,
I have homework and two tests tomorrow.
Mother: Better get
started then!
Works Cited
1. “BibleGateway."
Genesis 2 NASB. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2015
2. "Darwin's
Dangerous Idea." YouTube. YouTube, 27 July 2012. Web. 12 Oct. 2015.
3. Darwin, Charles.
Origin of Species. London: Charles Darwin, 1859. Gutenburg.org. Sue Asscher and
David Widger, 23 Nov. 2009. Web. 18 Oct. 2015.
4. Hudson, Roger.
"The Monkey Trial." History Today 65.7 (2015): 26-27. Academic Search
Complete. Web. 10 Nov. 2015.
5. Dawson, Jim.
"Evolution Wins In Pennsylvania, Loses In Kansas." Physics Today 59.1
(2006): 32-33. Academic Search Complete. Web. 10 Nov. 2015.
No comments:
Post a Comment